HomeNewsSuperyachtsMAIB: Bayesian vulnerable to knockdown at anchor

MAIB: Bayesian vulnerable to knockdown at anchor

The UK’s Marine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB) has found that the sailing yacht Bayesian was vulnerable to knockdown in severe winds when at anchor with no sails set, a risk that was not identified in its approved stability information and of which the crew were not aware.

At 0406 on 19 August 2024, the yacht was at anchor 0.5 nautical miles south-east of Porticello, Italy, when a downburst of hurricane-force winds knocked it onto its starboard side. Unable to right itself, Bayesian flooded and sank in 50m of water.

Six guests and one crew member died, including British tech tycoon Mike Lynch, 59, and his 18-year-old daughter Hannah; 15 people survived.

None of the liferafts on board inflated or released automatically, so the crew had to launch one manually.

They organised the survivors in the water and helped them into the liferaft. The crew of the sailing vessel Sir Robert Baden Powell saw the distress flares, sent their tender and recovered the survivors, who were then taken ashore.

Raised centreboard

The investigation found the yacht’s vulnerability was affected by its loading condition, the apparent wind angle and the position of the centreboard which was raised at the time of the sinking.

The report stated that the centreboard was not needed when Bayesian was under motor and was rarely used when the yacht was at anchor.

In addition, the yacht ‘had a vulnerability to high winds that was not recognised, because the yacht had never been assessed at anchor with its sails down’.

Guidance available to mariners lacked detail on the effect of weather conditions to support decision-making. The forecast, while largely correct, did not indicate the risk of downbursts from the predicted thunderstorms.

The Bayesian experienced wind speeds that rapidly escalated from 8 knots to around 70 knots within minutes, while the weather forecast had predicted gusts of up to 27 knots.

Extraordinary speed

The MAIB report also states that Bayesian could right itself up to a heel of 73°, but the vessel could not right itself once it passed this angle.

The mast contributed more than 56% of the wind heeling moment and the furled sails more than 20%.

“This accident developed with extraordinary speed,” said Rob Loder, chief inspector of marine accidents. “In just 14 minutes, calm conditions had given way to winds of at least 68 knots, which in less than 15 seconds pushed the yacht onto its side.”

He added: “Our investigation found that Bayesian had a vulnerability to high winds that was not recognised, because the yacht had never been assessed at anchor with its sails down. The extreme winds that night were also not explicitly forecast, so the crew had no warning of the risk.”

Recommendations

The MAIB recommends that the Red Ensign Group study the vulnerabilities and amend its Yacht Code, that the Maritime and Coastguard Agency add downburst risks to its yacht master syllabus, that the Met Office raise the representation of low-likelihood, high-impact hazards with the World Meteorological Organization, and that the UK Hydrographic Office update its guidance.

“I urge everyone with a part to play, including regulators, training providers and weather services, to read our report and act on it, so that a tragedy like this is not repeated,” Loder said.

The investigation was carried out alongside a criminal probe in Italy, where captain James Cutfield, chief engineer Tim Parker Eaton and watchstander Matthew Griffiths are under investigation over potential charges of multiple manslaughter and culpable shipwreck.

The MAIB’s findings appear to contrast with those of the Italian prosecutors’ experts, who have ruled out a design flaw.

RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular