HomeNewsSuperyachtsProsecutors rule out Bayesian design flaw

Prosecutors rule out Bayesian design flaw

Italian prosecutors investigating the sinking of the superyacht Bayesian have concluded that a design flaw can be ruled out, shifting their focus to the captain and crew, according to Italian media reports.

Seven people died when the 184ft Perini Navi sloop sank at anchor off Porticello, near Palermo, on 19 August 2024 during a violent storm.

The victims included British tech entrepreneur Mike Lynch and his daughter Hannah.

Experts appointed by the Termini Imerese prosecutor’s office describe the yacht as ‘a well-built vessel that has weathered ocean storms and has no design-related weaknesses’.

Their final report is expected by the end of the month, with a notice of completion of the investigation expected by Christmas.

Stability

The conclusion contrasts with the interim report published in May 2025 by the UK’s Marine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB), which focused on the yacht’s vulnerability in extreme weather, linked to changes made to accommodate her very tall mast.

Prosecutors say the centreboard, weighing more than 60 tonnes, was raised when the storm struck, cutting the yacht’s draught from 9.8 metres to 4.05 metres.

They argue that lowering it would have improved stability. However, the stability booklet reportedly requires the centreboard to be lowered when sailing, but does not explicitly require it at anchor, instead making the captain responsible for assessing risks.

The experts also described the weather as ‘little more than a squall’, saying it could have been managed. Reports cite gusts of up to 70 knots, and the yacht sank within about 27 minutes.

Underestimation

Three people are under investigation: captain James Cutfield, chief engineer Tim Parker Eaton and watchstander Matthew Griffiths.

Prosecutor Angelo Cavallo and deputy prosecutor Raffaele Cammarano believe Griffiths lacked the qualifications for the watch and that Parker Eaton failed to secure engine-room spaces.

The experts point to ‘a general underestimation of the event and a delay in responding to the deterioration in weather conditions’, for which the captain is also held responsible.

Investigators compared the crew’s conduct with that of the smaller sailing yacht Sir Robert Baden Powell, which came through the storm unscathed.

No charges have yet been brought, and a decision on whether to prosecute is pending. None of the three is being held in Italy.

Bayesian was raised in June 2025 and has been impounded at Termini Imerese.

RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular